* Deceased

2023 Richard Brister, Jr.
2022 Tim Morrissey
2021 Kevin Countryman
2020 Matt Bufano
2019 Christopher Schrank
2018 Matthew DePonti
2017 Tim Morrissey
2016 Mike Wiehl
2015 Scott Eskwitt
2014 Daniel J. Kane
2013 Derek S. DeBree
2012 William M. Heath
2011 Wade L. Davis
2010 James Cerruti
2008 Larry D. Hartman
2007 Robert Townshend
2006 Paul Lenskold
2005 Michael Reddy
2004 Robert Frank
2003 Martin L. Coy
2002 John T. Feeny
2001 John Riley, Jr.
2000 John W. Felsmann
1999 Christopher Conk
1998 James Butler III
1997 Andrew Schrank
1996 Darryl Breckenridge
1995 John Warren III
1994 Barry Brett*
1993 T. Stewart Watson
1992 James Kirman
1991 Carl Preston*
1990 Michael Foley
1989 Jack Mulvihill
1988 Carl Gerding
1987 Barry Brett*
1986 John Riley
1985 Michael DeFazio*
1984 Michael Connor
1983 David Binaco
1982 Larry D. Hartman
1981 Walter Conk
1980 John V. Feeny
1979 Raymond Bennett
1978 Dwight Havens*
1977 John Riley
1976 Douglas A. Sauer*
1975 Richard Brister, Sr.
1974 William Lang*
1973 John P. Felsmann*
1972 Clarence Cook*
1971 John Warren*
1970 Bernard A. Dupree*
1969 Charles Van Hart*
1968 William Lang*
1967 Arthur Bennett*
1966 John McQueen*
1965 James Acker*
1964 Joseph Connor*
1963 Robert Lundy*
1962 Richard Pettigrew, Sr.*
1961 Patrick Halleran*
1960 Dominic Paolucci*
1959 Bernard Rosenberg*
1958 James W. Connor*
1957 Lawrence J. Farley*
1956 Abel F. Maffeo*
1955 John P. Mulvihill, Jr.*
1954 James B. Costello*
1953 Robert Matthews*
1952 Charles Moeller, Jr.*
1951 William Robbins*
1950 Alfred Robbins*
1949 Thomas Carlock*
1948 Hubert Conover*
1947 Joseph Frank*
1946 Leonard Mack*
1945 Robert Van Brunt*
1944 Luke Pryor*
1943 Lester England*
1942 Barney T. Egeland*
1941 Abram C. Dixon *
1940 Charles Wesson*
1939 Herbert C. Hawkins*
1938 John F. Wagner*
1937 Robert Amendt*
1936 Oscar Becker, Sr.*
1935 William Anderson*
1934 Thomas Cleary*
1933 George W. Curchin*
1932 H. Lynwood Minton*
1931 Russell Hendrickson*
1930 Jacob Grimm*
1929 Leroy King*
1928 Vernon Little*
1927 Russell W. Bennett*
1926 Arthur Davison*
1925 Raymond Davison*
1924 Harry B. Kurtis*
1923 William C. Bennett*
1922 Charles P. Cross*
1921 William B. Little, Jr.*
1920 John P. Mulvihill*
1919 Clarence Little*
1918 Arthur B. Sickles*
1917 Joseph Hendrickson*
1916 Arthur Kettle*
1915-1916 Mortimer W. Curchin*
1914-1915 Matt Baden*
1913-1914 Charles VanBrunt*
1911-1913 Arthur E. Smith*
1909-1911 George Hendrickson*
1907-1909 John V. Woodward*
1904-1907 Frank Mulvihill*